Changing the key from a male to a female voice (and back): how far?
6 min read
When a female vocalist takes on a male artist's song, the original key causes one of two problems: the melody sits too low for her voice, or, sung an octave up, it gets too high. The fix is to change the key. This article covers how many semitones make a good starting point, why that works, how to test for the exact key, and what to do for duets and on guitar with a capo.
Hit a term you don’t know? Music terms glossary
Why change the key at all?
On average, female voices sit somewhere between a fourth and an octave above male voices. A chorus a male artist sings comfortably often falls below a woman's chest voice and comes out thin. Singing the same melody an octave higher puts the top notes out of reach instead. Because the voice's range lies somewhere between the two, most songs work best with a shift of a few semitones.
These are averages, not rules. A low female voice may sing a man's song comfortably in the original key, and a high male voice may sing a woman's song with no change at all. The decision always follows the singer's voice. To find your own range, see what key should I sing in.
The starting rule: up 5 semitones or down 7
Going from a male to a female voice, the first value to try is up 5 semitones (a perfect fourth). If the melody is already high, or the singer wants it lower, try down 7 semitones (a perfect fifth). On paper the two give the same chords: up 5 and down 7 are an octave apart and the chord names do not change. Only the singer hears the difference, when choosing which octave to sing the melody in.
| Original key | +5 / −7 | Original key | +5 / −7 |
|---|---|---|---|
| C | F | G | C |
| D | G | A | D |
| E | A | B♭ | E♭ |
| F | B♭ | B | E |
| Am | Dm | Em | Am |
| Dm | Gm | Bm | Em |
If a man is singing a woman's song, the same logic runs backwards: down 5 semitones or up 7. A female song in G often sits comfortably for a male voice in D.
Finding the exact key in three tries
- Find the highest and lowest points of the song. The highest is usually the peak of the chorus, the lowest the first line of a verse.
- Try +5 first and sing only those two spots. If the top note comes without strain and the low spot is still audible, that is the key.
- If the top strains, try +4, then +3; if the low spot disappears, try +6. Move a semitone at a time and sing the same two spots each time.
- Record the key you settle on and listen back the next day. A tired voice at rehearsal and a fresh voice on stage are not the same; leaving a semitone of headroom is often wise.
Duets: two voices, one key
If a man and a woman sing the song together, you have to choose a single key. There are three common ways:
- Split the sections. One sings the verse, the other the chorus; the key is chosen for whichever section is harder for its singer.
- Sing in octaves. Both voices sing the same melody an octave apart; the key is a middle point that is neither too low for him nor too high for her.
- Sing harmony. One voice takes the melody, the other a third or sixth above; the key is then chosen for the melody singer.
On guitar: capo or transpose?
When the key changes, the guitarist does one of two things: plays the chords of the new key directly, or puts on a capo and keeps the old shapes. If a song in G goes up to C, playing C shapes without a capo and G shapes with a capo at the 5th fret give the same key; capo 5 sounds brighter and thinner. Which fret gives which key is in the capo chart, and how chords are shifted is in how to transpose chords.
Changing the key in Songlivo
- Tap the target key directly in the “Key” strip, or step a semitone at a time with plus and minus on the “Transpose” row. The chords are rewritten in the new key instantly, and the bass notes of slash chords move with them. Since +5 and −7 give the same chords, tapping the target key on the strip is enough.
- The key you choose is saved with the song, so it opens in the same key next time. “Reset” takes it back to the original key.
- In stage mode the leader's key goes to every connected device at once. Members' key control is locked and shows “Key: leader”; the capo stays each player's own choice.
Songlivo keeps your songs and setlists on the device, remembers the key for each song and sends it to the whole band at once in stage mode. To move a song's chords to another key right now, use the transpose tool.
THE TOOL FOR THISChord transposer